September 22, 2026
Who Has the Final Say in Canada — Judges or Voters?
With Allan and Corri Hunsperger · Guest: John Carpay
What happens when a Canadian court strikes down a law but an elected government refuses to accept the result? John Carpay, president and founder of the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms, explains Section 33 of the Charter — the notwithstanding clause — why it was included in Canada’s Constitution and why he believes it is an important check on judicial power. Carpay discusses how Quebec, Ontario and Alberta have used the clause, its five-year limit, the debate surrounding Quebec’s Bill 21, and the broader question of who should ultimately shape Canadian law: elected legislatures or the courts.
Join our newsletter
The best of Talk Truth, straight to your inbox.
Catch the conversations you missed, see who’s coming on next, and get a word of encouragement from Allan and Corri.
In this episode
Tap a time to jump to that part of the conversation.
- 00:00 - Introduction
- 01:04 - Guest comes in: John Carpay
- 02:02 - What is the notwithstanding clause?
- 04:36 - Why Section 33 became controversial
- 06:47 - Why Carpay says it matters now
- 08:06 - A check on judicial power
- 09:49 - The five-year limit
- 10:29 - How provinces have used Section 33
- 13:38 - What is “juristocracy”?
- 15:56 - Why Section 33 was added to the Charter
- 18:41 - What Section 33 cannot do
- 19:40 - The Supreme Court and Bill 21
- 22:30 - Where to find Carpay’s report
- 24:48 - Psalm 24 and devotional
- 27:01 - Living in Truth
Stand with Talk Truth
Your support makes conversations like this possible. Together we can continue to shine a light in the darkness.